Page 16 of 18 FirstFirst ... 61415161718 LastLast
Results 151 to 160 of 179

Thread: Game of Thrones

  1. #151
    Moderator
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    334

    Default

    I guess the problem i have is they had the right formula in season 1 and they deviated from it. Stick as close to the source material as possible. Quit making up your own stuff. I totally get that they need to streamline and cut characters and even entire storylines. That is expected, they did that in season 1 and it worked fine. But when they tried to dumb down the storylines they did take from and make up their own twists and plots they just fell well short of GRRM's work and writing.

    I'm not a fanboy. But what Peter Jackson did with the lord of the rings was brilliant. He used technology to bring the original characters and story to life not try to make the story more palatable for modern day morons who want trashy daytime TV type plot twists and stereotypes...

    I'll say this. It's still must watch stuff but it makes me want to read the books even more...

    Season 1 = 5/5
    Season 2 = 4/5
    RIP Rocklobster & Straph

  2. #152
    Senior Member Kyrillian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    548

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Chadwick View Post
    I guess the problem i have is they had the right formula in season 1 and they deviated from it. Stick as close to the source material as possible. Quit making up your own stuff. I totally get that they need to streamline and cut characters and even entire storylines. That is expected, they did that in season 1 and it worked fine. But when they tried to dumb down the storylines they did take from and make up their own twists and plots they just fell well short of GRRM's work and writing.

    I'm not a fanboy. But what Peter Jackson did with the lord of the rings was brilliant. He used technology to bring the original characters and story to life not try to make the story more palatable for modern day morons who want trashy daytime TV type plot twists and stereotypes...

    I'll say this. It's still must watch stuff but it makes me want to read the books even more...

    Season 1 = 5/5
    Season 2 = 4/5
    Lord of the Rings also had a budget of like $300 million for 9-10 hours of film. I think I read GoT had a budget of $60 million for season 2's 10 hourlong episodes.

    I think the difficult thing they had to navigate was keeping their actors happy. Daenarys doesn't have a whole lot of activity in the book from what I understand for this season, so they added a little twist to her story.

    I don't really understand what the reason for tweaking Jon Snow's story was, that was only one I felt was completely unnecesssary.

  3. #153
    Moderator
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    334

    Default

    I think the Daenary storyline didnt need what they did to it and they should have flushed out the house of the undying to follow the book more...it was one of the best parts of the 2nd book.
    Last edited by Chadwick; 06-12-2012 at 09:11 PM.
    RIP Rocklobster & Straph

  4. #154
    Cynic Jomama's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Anchorage, AK
    Posts
    816

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Kyrillian View Post

    I don't really understand what the reason for tweaking Jon Snow's story was, that was only one I felt was completely unnecesssary.

    My guess is, its fucking goddamn expensive to shoot on location in Iceland... They kept it simple.. because ultimately they just need to get Jon Snow with the wildling army and King beyond the Wall right?? did they simplify it too much maybe, sure..

    They've mentioned this in the Wired articles, but S1 had several full blown tournament jousting scenes, where-as S2 showed two scenes that were supposed to be jousting, and they turned them into plan old man-on-man combat.. Why = $$$

    They are definitely using every bit of budget they have... Maybe HBO will give them a bump for S3?

    Fact is some shit just wont translate from book to film, or it will take way too much time and money... Something that can be explained, w/backstory and context in two pages in a book can be impossible to put to screen in a reasonable timeframe..

  5. #155
    Administrator Klaus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Minnesota
    Posts
    2,188

    Default

    Hot body but I am not a fan of her nose...





    Anyway I thought the Daenary storyline in the book was super boring and actually in this case prefer the shows version.

  6. #156

  7. #157
    Administrator Klaus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Minnesota
    Posts
    2,188

    Default

    Interview with George Martin:

    HBO Since the last time we spoke with you, ‘Game of Thrones' has found the same great success as a TV show that it already had as a book series. What's it like see your story told in two places?

    George R.R. Martin We really have two audiences now, which is a unique challenge for a TV show. We have the viewers who are coming to the TV show without any knowledge of the books. And we have the readers, who have read the books, many times in many cases. Sometimes those two audiences give very different reactions to the same things. For the viewers experiencing it for the first time, it's just a matter of, "Is it exciting? Is it involving?" The readers care about those things, too, but they're also saying, "Well, this is how it was in the books ..."

    HBO You wrote the script for the episode "Blackwater," which aired recently -- was it difficult for you to translate your vision from the books onto the screen?

    George R.R. Martin It's very difficult. Prose and film have different techniques and weapons that they use. In a book, I have internal monologue and can give you access to a character's thoughts. He can tell a lie, but you're in his head, so you know he's lying. While you're watching on the screen, you're just hearing what he's saying -- the actor has to sell it with his eyes and the set of his mouth. And great actors can do that. Each of these mediums has its own strengths and weaknesses, and when you're moving from one to the other, it's always a challenge. If you look at the Battle of the Blackwater in the books, it occupies seven or eight chapters, intercutting from three points of view. If you shot it as I wrote it in the book, it would cost $100 million and take two months to shoot.

    HBO And the entire story is so complex. When you're working on the books, how difficult is it to weigh and keep track of all your decisions?

    George R.R. Martin Sometimes I make the decisions wrongly. My process as a writer is not one of thoroughly outlining ahead of time, which can result in my muse leading me down blind alleys and dead ends. I write a chapter and it seems great in and of itself, but then I realize a month later or half a year later that I don't want to go down that street. So then I have to double back and rewrite and so forth. It's almost a subconscious thing -- when it's right, it feels right, and when it doesn't feel right, I keep niggling at it until it does.

    HBO In the season finale, one of everyone's favorite characters, Tyrion Lannister, finds himself in a miserable position. Was it hard for you to smack him down so quickly after his moment of triumph?

    George R.R. Martin Well, you know, you don't want to make it too easy for the characters. If the character just goes from success to success, then you don't have much of a story, now do you? But I guess it's one of my trademarks as an author to always ask the question, "OK, what next?" We see a lot of books and movies and television shows, where you see some situation come up and then the resolution of it along pretty traditional -- or even stereotypical -- lines. That's great, but what happens next? We see this with Theon and taking Winterfell. "OK, Theon, you very cleverly tricked the Starks. Singers will sing of this for hundreds of years ... What's next? How do you hang onto this?" That question, on a whole bunch of levels, has always fascinated me, and there's a lot of that in "A Song of Ice and Fire."

    HBO One final question on behalf of all your fans -- how's the next book coming?

    George R.R. Martin I'm working on that, and a number of "Ice and Fire" related things at the same time. Not only "The Winds of Winter," which is Book 6, but we're also coming out with a big concordance called "The World of Ice and Fire," which is about the whole history of Westeros and will be lavishly illustrated. So I've been filling in some of the histories of the kings who ruled 200 years ago or 500 years ago. We've also been doing a map book, and I'm working on a new novella about Dunk and Egg, the prequel series I have. It's a slow process the way I write, especially books of this size that are as large and complex as they are. It's still a slow process. I am aware of the TV series moving along behind me like a giant locomotive, and I know I need to lay the track more quickly, perhaps, because the locomotive is soon going to be bearing down on me. The last thing I want is for the TV series to catch up with me. I've got a considerable headstart, but production is moving faster than I can write. I'm hoping that we'll finish the story at about the same time... we'll see.

  8. #158
    Administrator Klaus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Minnesota
    Posts
    2,188

    Default


  9. #159
    Administrator Klaus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Minnesota
    Posts
    2,188

    Default


  10. #160
    Administrator Klaus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Minnesota
    Posts
    2,188

    Default


Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •